Podiatrist discussing custom insoles and orthotic options with a patient at a consultation desk

Loub Job vs Insoles: Comparing Two Paths to Foot Comfort

Two Different Fixes for a Sore Foot

A Loub Job® is a quick in-office injection of hyaluronic acid filler that adds cushioning under the ball of the foot. Insoles go in your shoe instead: store-bought inserts add general padding, and custom orthotics are made from a mold of your feet to support how they line up as you walk.

Both aim at the same thing, a foot that hurts less with every step. They work in very different places, though, so the better choice depends on why your foot hurts. The tables below compare the two side by side.

Loub Job vs Insoles at a Glance

Main differences
Loub JobInsoles and orthotics
What it doesAdds volume under the bones of the forefootSupports and positions the foot from inside the shoe
Where it worksIn the foot itself, so it goes with you into any shoe, including sandals and heelsOnly in shoes that fit an insert; it has to be moved from pair to pair
Fixes alignment?No. Filler cannot correct a collapsing archYes, custom orthotics are built for this
Rebuilds padding?Yes, this is its main jobNo. An insert cannot restore a thin fat pad
Time involvedOne visit; most sessions take under 30 minutesStore-bought: same day. Custom: an exam and mold, then a fitting
Dr. Levine walks through her Pillows For Your Feet® treatment for fat loss on the bottom of the foot, which can cause pain and burning in the ball of the foot.

Conditions Each One Treats

Conditions treated
Loub JobInsoles and orthotics
Main problemLost natural padding under the ball of the footFoot structure and how the foot moves as you walk
Common conditionsFat pad atrophy; pain and burning in the ball of the foot; metatarsalgia; forefoot pain from heels; added cushioning for forefoot arthritisFlat foot; plantar fasciitis; Achilles tendinitis; arch and heel strain; mild soreness after long days (store-bought)
What it will not doCorrect the arch or how your foot strikes the groundRebuild a thin fat pad under the bones

Burning under the ball of the foot often points to thinning padding. Arch or heel pain often points to alignment. Some patients have both, and an exam is the fastest way to tell them apart.

A woman sits on a sofa holding her bare foot in discomfort, illustrating foot pain associated with fat pad atrophy

Cost Difference

Cost comparison
OptionTypical costWhat to know
Loub Job$500 to $1,500 in New York CityDepends on the provider and how much filler is used
Custom orthotics$300 to $800 in New YorkDepends on the provider and the materials used
Store-bought insolesUsually much less than custom orthoticsStandard sizes; they wear out and need replacing

These ranges come from the treatment pages on our site. Your own price depends on your feet and your plan, so ask for a personal quote at your consultation, along with whether your insurance plays any part.

Who Is a Good Candidate for Each?

Good candidates
Loub JobInsoles and orthotics
Good fit forFrequent high-heel wearers; people whose foot padding has thinned with age; patients with forefoot arthritis who want to avoid or delay surgery; anyone with forefoot pressure or sorenessPeople with flat feet, plantar fasciitis or Achilles strain; pain that keeps coming back; anyone whose foot structure or gait is part of the problem
Store-bought is enough whenNot applicableSoreness is mild and comes from long days on your feet, or you want a better grip inside your shoes
Not the right fit whenThe pain comes from alignment, not lost paddingThe pain comes from a thin fat pad under the bones
Dr. Suzanne Levine recommends wearing insoles to help women get a better and safer grip when wearing high heels.

When Combining Both Makes Sense

A Loub Job and custom orthotics do not compete with each other. Patients with thinning padding and a flat or rolling foot can use filler to cushion the forefoot and orthotics to support the arch. Orthotics can also help when foot mechanics add to knee discomfort.

Two people examine blue custom orthotic insoles alongside a foot pressure scan report and laptop on a desk

Finding Out Which One You Need

Dr. Suzanne Levine, a Board-Certified Podiatrist, examines your feet and watches how you walk. When needed, she uses X-rays taken in our office. You leave knowing what is causing the pain and whether a Loub Job, orthotics or both make sense. See all of our foot treatments, including heel comfort injections, or read more about Dr. Levine.

Dr. Suzanne Levine gives a cushioning injection into the ball of a patient's foot in her Park Avenue office
Female podiatrist in white coat smiling at camera in clinical setting

About the Author

Dr. Suzanne Levine

Named one of America’s Top Podiatrists and is one of the most internationally acclaimed podiatrists in the industry.

SCHEDULE YOUR CONSULTATION
Female healthcare provider headshot wearing white coat
Dr. Suzanne Levine

November 9, 2026